0 Burczak, Theodore 2004 Rethinking Marxism 16 207--209 This paper offers a comment on George DeMartino's insightful paper that proposes a tripartite notion of class justice. For DeMartino, class justice involves productive justice, appropriative justice, and distributive justice. The paper argues for a strong definition of appropriative justice, which would limit appropriation to productive workers, as would exist in the case of worker-owned firms. It argues against a weak definition of appropriative justice, which would permit appropriation by the entire community, because of its association with the widely discredited model of central planning.